Not Yo Mama’s Pizza Grilled Cheese

ADAI Recipe Cowspot Not Yo Mamas Grilled Cheese

Ingredients

2 slices firm white bread

3 tbsp marinara sauce

1 slice Mozzarella cheese

1 slice extra sharp Cheddar cheese

2 tbsp butter

1 ¼ tsp minced garlic

1 tsp finely chopped fresh basil

1 tsp finely chopped fresh oregano

½ tsp grated Parmesan cheese

SHARE THIS RECIPE

Directions

  • Place bread on cutting board; spread one side of each bread slice evenly with marinara sauce.
  • Top one bread slice with Mozzarella, Cheddar and tomatoes then second bread slice, marinara-side down.
  • Melt butter in skillet over medium-low heat.
  • Add garlic, basil and oregano and sauté until garlic is fragrant and golden.
  • Place sandwich in skillet and cook until golden brown; flip and sprinkle with Parmesan cheese.
  • Cover skillet and cook until second side is golden brown.
  • Remove from skillet and cut in half. Garnish with parsley if desired.

Explore more of our Dairy-licious recipes

ADAI Recipe Perfectly Peachy Grilled Cheese
Ultimate Grilled Cheese

Perfectly Peachy Grilled Cheese

view recipe
ADAI Recipe Not Yo Mamas Grilled Cheese
Ultimate Grilled Cheese

Not Yo Mama’s Pizza Grilled Cheese

view recipe
ADAI Recipe Inside Out Grilled Cheese
Ultimate Grilled Cheese

Inside Out Grilled Cheese

view recipe
ADAI Recipe Grilled Waffle Cheese Tot
Ultimate Grilled Cheese

Grilled Waffle Cheese Tot

view recipe
ADAI Recipe Blue Ribbon Blueberry Pie and Baby Swiss Grilled Cheese
Ultimate Grilled Cheese

Blue Ribbon Blueberry Pie and Baby Swiss Grilled Cheese

view recipe
ADAI Recipes Square Image Dads famous Homemade Vanilla Ice Cream
Dessert

Dad’s Famous Homemade Ice Cream

view recipe
ADAI Recipes Square Image Chocolate Almond Ice Cream
Dessert

Chocolate Almond Ice Cream

view recipe
ADAI Recipes Square Image Easy Mac and Cheese
Entrees

Easy Mac and Cheese

view recipe
ADAI Recipes Square Image Mousetrap Grilled Cheese
Ultimate Grilled Cheese

The Mousetrap Grilled Cheese

view recipe
ADAI Recipes Square Image Spicy Grilled Queso Grilled Cheese
Ultimate Grilled Cheese

Spicy Queso Grilled Cheese

view recipe

Love Our Delicious
Dairy Recipes?

Meet The Indiana dairy farmers who bring you the milk, cheese and yogurt you love.

Meet Our Farmers
Join Our Newsletter
Winners Drink Milk cow head icon white transparent
DairyBar_Icon_white

8425 Keystone Crossing, Ste 260
Indianapolis, IN 46240
317-842-3060

Proud to champion the Indiana Farmers’ Dairy Bar since 1941®

Contact Us

Sitemap

Copyright© 2025 American Dairy Association Indiana, Inc.